Skip to main content

The 10 Most Attractive Girls Derek Jeter Dated Before Marrying Hannah Davis

Sports Illustrated supermodel Hannah Davis has done the unthinkable - she's managed to tie down former New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter, one of the most famous sports bachelors of all-time. Davis and Jeter wed this past weekend in California in what's been described as an "intimate" affair. 

Jeter, during his 20-year career, won the World Series five times, registered over 3,400 hits and was named an All-Star 14 times. But that's not what we're focusing on here.

Before marrying Davis, Jeter dated a number of other celebrities. In fact, ESPN even once put together a "starting" lineup for Jeter, which features 10 of his most famous former hookups.

Davis, undoubtedly, belongs on that list. Here are the other nine ladies who'd be on his squad.

Next: Scarlett Johansson >>>

Scarlett Johannson

Jeter and ScarJo reportedly dated briefly back in December of 2004 - long before she married fellow movie star Ryan Reynolds. Jeter, by then 30 years old, had already won four World Series titles.

">July 2, 2016

Next: Jessica Alba >>>Jessica AlbaJeter also dated movie star Jessica Alba in 2004 - over the summer. Alba, at that point, was still a rising star in Hollywood.

Next: Adriana Lima >>>Adriana LimaJeter, back in 2006, moved away from movie stars to land the beautiful Adriana Lima - a Victoria's Secret supermodel. Tough life.

Next: Jordanna Brewster >>> Jordanna BrewsterIn 2003, Jeter was reportedly dating Jordanna Brewster of Fast & Furious fame. They didn't last long though.

">March 28, 2016

Next: Mariah Carey >>>

Mariah Carey

Jeter dated pop superstar Mariah Carey back in the late 1990s during the Yankees' dynasty era. She later married Nick Cannon.

Next: Vanessa Minnillo >>>

Vanessa Minnillo

Minnillo, before dating and marrying Nick Lachey, dated Jeter off and on for about two years. She's a former Miss Teen USA and a television host.


— Diego Marentes (@DMarentes_001)

— Diego Marentes (@DMarentes_001) June 4, 2015

">June 4, 2015

Next: Tyra Banks >>>

Tyra Banks

The timetable on Jeter dating Banks isn't exactly known, but it's been widely reported that the two were briefly an item.

">@tyrabanks every single dayyy!!
Love you Ty

— dR (@dRVlogs) June 28, 2016

Next: Jessica Biel >>>

Jessica Biel

Biel and Jeter were reportedly dating from 2006-2007 - before Justin Timberlake swooped in. 

Next: Minka Kelly >>>

Minka Kelly

There were many who believed Jeter would settle down with Kelly, who he dated for three years from 2008-2011. But it wasn't meant to be.

Next: 10 NBA Stars Who Could Eventually Come Home >>>