Matt Leinart - USC (2004)
Yes, technically this national title has been vacated after the Reggie Bush scandal, but it still happened. Leinart, the Heisman Trophy winner, led USC to a 13-0 season, complete with a 55-19 drubbing of Oklahoma in the Orange Bowl.
He was eventually drafted tenth overall in 2006, but he never lived up to the hype that surrounded him in college. He’s currently a member of the Oakland Raiders, after spending the past few years in Arizona and Houston.